Indian citizenship to depend on religion: Communal Nature of Indian State shows through its Secular Facade

The Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016 is likely to be tabled in the Monsoon session of the Parliament this year. This Bill amends the Citizenship Act, 1955 to relax the eligibility requirements for Indian citizenship for migrants who are Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis and Christians from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan.

The Constitution of India under Article 8 makes it possible for anyone whose parents or grand-parents were born in India to acquire Indian citizenship. Others can get Indian citizenship by naturalisation, for which that applicant must have resided in India during the last 12 months, and for 11 of the previous 14 years. The Bill, if passed, will redefine migrants of the six religions and from the three countries as legal even if they do not have valid visas and also relax the 11 year residency requirement to six years.

Several people have already pointed out that the reference to specific religions in the Bill, with the exclusion of Islam, is contradictory to the claim of the "secular foundations" of the Indian State. Islam is conspicuously absent in the list of religions listed in the proposed amendment.

This is clear-cut discrimination on the basis of religion. The stated objective of the Bill is to assist illegal migrants belonging to the six religions who want to make India their homeland. But the question naturally arises – why only the illegal migrants belonging to these religions and not others who may be Muslims or some other religion or those who may not be religious at all?

Implicit justification for the Bill is that people belonging to these six religions constitute religious minorities in the above-mentioned three countries and therefore may be persecuted there. However, people do not get persecuted only because of their religion. Many are persecuted for their nationality, for demanding their rights and for many other reasons. So clearly the Bill is not intended to help those who want to take refuge in India because of persecution in these countries. If that was the intent, then there is no need to mention any religion in the Bill.

On the other hand, if the Bill is implicitly aimed to undo a historical injustice done at the time of partition in 1947, i.e., to help those who for some reason ended up in the wrong side, then again, mention of any religion is uncalled for. Many people of Muslim faith chose to remain in India and there may be others today in these three countries who may want to choose India as their homeland for uniting with their families or for any other valid reason.

In either of these cases, there is no justification for discrimination on the basis of religion.

The Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016 reveals the communal nature of the Indian state beneath its secular facade.


Share Everywhere

communal    citizenship    Mar 1-15 2017    Struggle for Rights    Rights     2017   


Click to Download PDFInterview with Comrade Lal Singh, General Secretary of Communist Ghadar Party of India

by Comrade Chandra Bhan, Editor of Mazdoor Ekta Lehar

(Click thumbnail to download PDF)

History of Ghadar PartyA Presentation of Communist Ghadar Party of India

100 years ago Ghadar Party was formed by Indians in the US.It was historic milestone in our anti-colonial struggle.

The goal of this party was to organise a revolution to liberate our motherland from British servitude and establish a free and independent India with equal rights for all. It believed this to be the necessary condition for our people to hold their heads high anywhere in the world.

(Click thumbnail to download PDF)

Call of the Central Committee of Communist Ghadar Party of India, 30th August, 2012

Working class representatives from all over the country are gathering on 4th September, at a time when a titanic struggle is going on in our country. The struggle is between the majority of toiling and exploited people and a minority of exploiters. It is between the majority whose labour expands wealth and the minority who enjoy the fruits of wealth creation on the basis of their private property and positions of power.

(Click thumbnail to download PDF)

Call to the Working ClassDefeat the program of privatisation and liberalisation!

Fight with the aim of establishing workers’ and peasants’ rule!

Call of the Central Committee, Communist Ghadar Party, 23 February, 2012

(Click thumbnail to download PDF)

Necessity for the working class to take political powerThe initiating speech, at the working class conference on the Way Forward held on 23-24 December 2011, was made by comrade Lal Singh, on behalf of the Central Committee of the Communist Ghadar Party of India. The document entitled the necessity for the working class to take political power has been edited based on the discussion in the conference and is being published according to the decision the Central Committee.

(Click thumbnail to download PDF)

Power to DecideVoice of the Communist Ghadar Party of India on the Power to Decide

This publication contains three statements issued by the Central Committee of Communist Ghadar Party on 1st, 18th & 28th Aug, 2011.

(Click thumbnail to download PDF)